Senators Hear Grassroots Drumbeat on Net Neutrality
July 24th, 2006 by tkarr |
Senator Ron Wyden (D-Oregon) spoke before the Senate on Friday to “outline what is at stake” should Congress ignore public opinion and let phone and cable companies gut Net Neutrality.
“If you listen to some of the so-called experts about communications, they would suggest that [Net Neutrality] is so complicated, so arcane, so difficult for anybody to understand, you ought to let the lawyers and the lobbyists sort this out,” Wyden told his colleagues.
This is a mistake, Wyden said.
Thus far powerful phone and cable companies have spent an estimated $100 million on lobbyists, lawyers, “Astroturf” groups, campaign contributions and advertising agencies in a drive to dismantle Net Neutrality and mislead Americans.
According to Campaign Media Analysis Group, they have spent up to $45 million to buy anti-Net Neutrality ads nationwide. A report by Bloomberg News, estimates an additional $50 million spent on telco and cable lobbyists. Add to this tally the millons in campaign contributions made by anti-Neutrality companies like AT&T, Verizon, BellSouth, Cisco, Comcast and Time Warner.
On the other hand, the many groups that constitute the SavetheInternet coalition have spent less than $200,000 in our grassroots campaign to support Net Neutrality.
That means that for every $1 spent by the grassroots to defend Net Neutrality, the phone and cable companies have spent approximately $500 to drown it.
Still, public sentiment is tipping against their scheme to turn the “pipes” into private toll roads.
No amount of PR gloss will obscure one basic truth. According to Wyden: “The people of this country — and the hundreds and hundreds of organizations that want to keep the Internet discrimination free — are no longer going to accept a notion that a handful of insiders in Washington, DC, can have these debates about the future of the communications systems… and that the people of this country will have to take what these so-called experts decide.”
People of every political persuasion have joined with the 800 groups that make up the SavetheInternet coalition. More than a million of them have signed petitions and called and sent letters to Congress in support of Net Neutrality.
Thousands of bloggers have taken up the cause — many of them posting free ads to counteract the expensive misinformation campaign launched by phone companies. Others have organized in their communities — printing out fliers and handing them out at high school soccer matches, in electronics shops, outside college dorms and in front of grocery stores.
Wyden is among a growing group of senators who have heard the grassroots drumbeat. They are now supporting Net Neutrality legislation that would prevent phone and cable companies from discriminating against online choice.
For a sense of the passions that drive this debate, listen to some of their statements before Congress:
- Sen. Olympia Snowe compares the telco plan to a “Soviet Union Supermarket”.
- Sen. Snowe talks about the shortcomings of the Internet “dirt road”.
- Sen. Barbara Boxer lists SavetheInternet’s grassroots composition over protests from Sen. Ted Stevens.
- Sen. John Kerry discusses telcos’ intention to discriminate and legislate their monopoly control.
- Sen. Byron Dorgan challeneges Sen. Stevens to prove non-discrimination language in his bill.
Sen. Wyden closed his speech on Friday saying he was dismayed that phone and cable companies wanted to bring discrimination back to the Internet. “I do not want to see the American consumer face the double barrel discrimination on the net of reduced choices in content, diminished services, and the additional prospect of higher prices,” Wyden said.
The Oregon Senator is committed to maintain his “hold” against Stevens’ telecommunications rewrite “until it ensures true Net neutrality and an Internet free of discrimination,” he said.
As more Senators side with Wyden and the public, it’s become increasingly likely that no amount of phone and cable company money will force Sen. Stevens’ bad bill through Congress without better public protections.
But the fight to preserve Internet freedom from predatory phone and cable giants is far from over. As members of Congress return to their home districts this August, it’s up to Americans in every state to let them know that Net Neutrality is an issue that resonates more loudly beyond the beltway.
= = = =
July 27 UPDATE: Listen to Sen Wyden’s newest speech — delivered before the Senate today.
July 24th, 2006 at 11:49 pm
http://business.newsforge.com/business/06/07/19/206209.shtml?tid=138&tid=3&netneutralityisgood
This is an interesting article, which describes what cell phone companies (in particular, Verizon) have done with their private networks. The article concludes by suggesting that it’s not unreasonable to expect the telcos to put similar restrictions on their internet services once they’ve been deregulated.
JR
July 26th, 2006 at 7:47 am
What is it with you americans that you EVER give credit to opinions that have ben PAID to be so ?
I am talking about these so called ‘lobby’ corporations. These people are PAID to make others believe in something, whether it is true or not.
It is NOT opinion, it is PROPAGANDA.
The only difference it has from what Nazis done with Goebbels is that it is PAID.
I hate the concept of the nazi, but telling the truth, Goebbels is more honest in that at least HE BELIEVED IN what he was advocating. He wasnt just the mouthpiece of anyone who have paid him.
This is just stupid. Such ‘lobby’ corporations need to be BANNED. This is not ‘freedom of business’ - it is 21st century’s paid people fooling.
And senators ? Senators who voice utterly ridiculous ‘opinions’ about something which they do not have the slightest idea about, after getting some amount of ‘donation’ from any company ?
Is this the U.S. system of government ?!?!
Oh boy. It makes one long for monarchies.
July 26th, 2006 at 7:55 am
The internet, is in its current state, have been an inbeatable tool for creeping democracy in places that has no freedom, like china.
This in turn creates a pressure in these countries for more democratical, more compatible policies with the rest of the world.
Handing over of the internet to a small number of corporations, which will turn it to a media that can be controlled only through them will make a splendid example for such countries, who are already trying to stomp down freedom creeping in through the internet into their countries.
Result will be the salvation of regimes like iran, korea, the arab dictatorships and will make it easy for hardliners in china to get their way with the country.
And what, would this result lead to, can anyone guess ?
Yea, u.s. citizens will have to die in distant wars in distant lands to protect u.s. democracy from threats, and bring democracy to these countries.
Far fetched ?
NO. Something that is already happening does not need to be far fetched - it can be only real.
August 24th, 2006 at 6:29 pm
[…] http://www.savetheinternet.com/blog/2006/07/24/more-senators-respond-to-the-grassroots-drumbeat/ […]
January 26th, 2008 at 1:15 pm
[…] on The Hill, and it was only due to the outstanding work by NGOs such as Free Press and the mobilization of over 1 million citizens that Sen. Ted Stevens’ (R-AK) 2006 telecom bill died as a net neutrality […]